• Home
    • View
    • Login
    This page
    • Normal
    • Export PDF
    • Page Information

    Loading...
  1. Dashboard
  2. Undefined Space
  3. Compatibility & Specification Review
  4. CSR FAQs

Page History

Versions Compared

Old Version 2

changes.mady.by.user Joe Darcy

Saved on Apr 19, 2017

compared with

New Version 3

changes.mady.by.user Joe Darcy

Saved on Apr 20, 2017

  • Previous Change: Difference between versions 1 and 2
  • Next Change: Difference between versions 3 and 4
  • View Page History

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Q: How many CSR requests are typically in a release?
A: For JDK 9, there were approximately 900 CCC requests (the CCC being the internal predecessor to the CSR), approximately 90 JEPs, and over 14,000 bug fixes. Having a single-digit percentage of fixes need to go through compatibility and specification review has been consistent over time.

Q: I found a case where the specification and implementation disagree; how is this resolved?
A: The proper resolution depends on the nature of the discrepancy. However, if it is technically reasonable for either the specification to be changed to match the implementation or for the implementation to be changed to match the specification, the preference is to change the specification to match the implementation. This preference better preserves behavioral compatibility for users of the API in question. Note this is only a preference and at times it is unreasonable to allow erroneous behavior of the implementation, once recognized, to persist.

(Future FAQ items will discuss the logistics of working with CSR issues in JBS.)

Overview
Content Tools
ThemeBuilder

Terms of Use
• License: GPLv2
• Privacy • Trademarks • Contact Us

Powered by a free Atlassian Confluence Open Source Project License granted to https://www.atlassian.com/software/views/opensource-community-additional-license-offer. Evaluate Confluence today.

  • Kolekti ThemeBuilder Powered by Atlassian Confluence 8.5.23
  • Kolekti ThemeBuilder printed.by.atlassian.confluence
  • Report a bug
  • Atlassian News
Atlassian
Kolekti ThemeBuilder EngineAtlassian Confluence
{"serverDuration": 292, "requestCorrelationId": "2b7688172b823b61"}